CRISIS OF TRUTH

Case File · War & Accountability · November 2026

War Is a
Racket.

A Marine general with two Medals of Honor said it in 1935. The record since then keeps proving him right: a revolutionary's letters left unanswered, an election blocked, an attack that never happened, a witness coached by a PR firm, weapons that weren't there. The contractors got paid every time. Working families paid in sons and daughters.

58,220U.S. military fatal casualties of the Vietnam War in the Defense Department's casualty fileNational Archives [48]
~90%Share of the Gulf of Tonkin signals intelligence kept out of the NSA's reports, per the agency's own historianNSA / Hanyok [30]
70%Weight a Pentagon official gave to avoiding a "humiliating US defeat" as the reason to stay in Vietnam. Helping the Vietnamese: 10%.Pentagon Papers [36]
$39.5BIraq war contracts awarded to KBR, the company Dick Cheney once ranFinancial Times analysis [62]
Illustration: the words War Is a Racket beside soldiers advancing through smoke under a helicopter, while men in suits sit with cigars on piles of cash in front of the Capitol. Text reads: The rich profit. The powerful gain control. The poor pay the price, with their money and their lives. A list titled The Wars in This Investigation names the USS Maine and Spanish-American War (1898), World War I profiteers (1914 to 1918), Vietnam (1955 to 1975), the Gulf War (1991), Afghanistan (2001 to 2021) and Iraq (2003 to 2011). The bottom line reads: A pattern repeated for over a century: sell a threat, build support, go to war, share the profits.

The video that started this case file: "The True Origin of the Vietnam War: What Historians Get Wrong." We checked it claim by claim. Most of it holds up. Several specifics do not, and those are in Quarantine. [72]

The Witness

The General Who Told the Truth

Smedley Darlington Butler spent more than three decades in the Marine Corps fighting America's wars. Then he spent the rest of his life telling Americans who those wars were really for.

VerifiedMedal of Honor · Veracruz, Mexico, 1914 · Medal of Honor · Fort Rivière, Haiti, 1915
Butler was one of only two Marines ever to receive two Medals of Honor for separate acts of heroism. [3] Nobody can call him a coward or a peacenik who never served.

VerifiedAfter retiring in October 1931, he toured the country giving a speech called "War Is a Racket." It drew such a response that he expanded it into a short book, published in 1935. [1]

"War is a racket. It always has been."Maj. Gen. Smedley D. Butler, War Is a Racket, 1935 [2]

He named the customers

VerifiedIn the November 1935 issue of the magazine Common Sense, Butler described his own career as muscle for Wall Street and the banks. [5] He listed the jobs one by one:

"In short, I was a racketeer, a gangster for capitalism."Butler, Common Sense, Vol. 4, No. 11, November 1935 [5]

AttributedThe places he occupied remember him differently. Journalist Jonathan M. Katz, who retraced Butler's path, reports that in Haiti he was known simply as "The Devil." [11]

He stopped a coup and nobody went to jail

VerifiedIn November 1934 Butler testified under oath before the House committee known as the McCormack–Dickstein Committee. He said wealthy businessmen had tried to recruit him to lead a fascist movement against President Franklin Roosevelt. The men he named all denied it. [6] Newspapers began mocking his account almost immediately. [8]

VerifiedThe committee's February 1935 report said it had obtained evidence that certain persons had attempted to establish a fascist organization in the country. [7] No one was ever prosecuted. [6]

His fix: take the profit out

VerifiedButler's book ends with a plan to "smash" the racket. The first step was to make war unprofitable. [1] He proposed conscripting capital and industry, and holding their pay to a soldier's wage, before a single young man was drafted. He wanted any declaration of war put to a vote of the people who would actually have to fight, and he wanted the military limited to defending American soil. [2]

Congress looked, then looked away

VerifiedButler was not alone. From 1934 to 1936 the Senate's Special Committee on Investigation of the Munitions Industry, led by Sen. Gerald Nye (R-N.D.), investigated the "merchants of death" who profited from World War I. It found the arms industry had engaged in price-fixing and held excessive influence over foreign policy before and during that war. [10]

VerifiedThe investigation ended abruptly. The Senate cut off its funding after Nye attacked the late President Woodrow Wilson for withholding information from Congress before it declared war. The hearings did produce three neutrality acts. [9]

Read Butler yourself

  • War Is a Racket (Round Table Press, 1935). The full text is free on the Internet Archive. [2]
  • "America's Armed Forces," Common Sense, November 1935, the "gangster for capitalism" article. [5]
  • His 1934 McCormack–Dickstein testimony, reproduced in full by the Cato Institute's Libertarianism.org. [8]
  • Gangsters of Capitalism by Jonathan M. Katz, which follows Butler from Cuba to the Philippines to Nicaragua to Haiti. [11]
  • Old Gimlet Eye by Lowell Thomas (1933), his life story as told at the time. [1]

Butler's test

Butler's argument comes down to three questions you can ask of any war. Who told the public why we were going? Who made money? Who did the dying? The rest of this page asks those three questions of five wars. The pattern is hard to miss.

Count One · 1898

Remember the Maine

The pattern is older than any living American. The first modern American war began with an explosion, a headline, and a villain picked before anyone looked.

VerifiedThe battleship USS Maine blew up in Havana harbor in February 1898. American newspapers blamed Spain, and "Remember the Maine!" became the battle cry of the Spanish-American War. [12]

VerifiedSpain's own inquiry at the time concluded that a spontaneous fire in a coal bunker next to a magazine caused the blast. Two U.S. Navy boards disagreed. [12]

DisputedIn 1976, Adm. Hyman Rickover's study found no technical evidence that an outside explosion started the destruction. It concluded the most likely cause was heat from a coal-bunker fire next to a magazine, while noting this could not be proven. [13] A 1998 National Geographic study reopened the question and could not rule out a mine. [13]

Either way, the country went to war on a blame nobody had established. Smedley Butler was 16 when it started. He joined the Marines for it.

The Centerpiece · Vietnam, 1880s–1975

Who Ran the Show

Most Americans know the end of this story: the wall in Washington, the helicopters on the roof. The decisions that put 58,220 names on that wall were made decades earlier, in offices, by men who left a paper trail.

Count Two · The Colony

Rubber, Blood and Michelin

VerifiedFrance ruled Vietnam as part of French Indochina from the late 1800s. Rubber plantations in the south fed the booming French auto and tire industry. The largest Michelin plantation was Phu Rieng. [15]

VerifiedIn 1927, Tran Tu Binh was one of 17,606 laborers brought to work at Phu Rieng. His memoir, The Red Earth, is a firsthand account of what happened there. [14] Official colonial records showed 17 percent of Phu Rieng workers died in 1927 alone. That figure may be low, because the plantation's own supervisors had reason to hide losses. [15]

VerifiedOn February 3, 1930, more than 5,000 workers rose up, held the plantation for four days, and forced the French supervisor to agree to better conditions before the revolt was crushed. Binh was sent to the prison island of Con Dao. [15]

VerifiedThe plantation also gave birth to the opposition. The first Communist Party cell in southeastern Vietnam was founded at Phu Rieng in October 1929. [16] The colony built its own enemy.

Count Three · 1945–1950

The Ally They Dropped

The first Americans to fight in Vietnam fought on Ho Chi Minh's side.

VerifiedIn July 1945, the Office of Strategic Services, the forerunner of the CIA, sent an eight-man team under Maj. Allison K. Thomas into northern Indochina to work with Ho's Viet Minh against the Japanese. [18][17] The team's medic, Paul Hoagland, treated a seriously ill Ho. Thomas later said he had no idea at the time that Ho was a Communist. [19]

VerifiedOn September 2, 1945, Ho declared Vietnam's independence. He deliberately opened with words from the American Declaration of Independence. [20]

  1. VerifiedPresident Franklin Roosevelt puts his opposition to continued French rule of Vietnam in writing. [21]
  2. VerifiedHo sends letters and telegrams to President Truman asking for American support. Truman does not reply. [21] The U.S. adopts a neutral policy as France goes to war to retake Vietnam. [20]
  3. VerifiedTruman approves $10 million in military aid for the French war in Indochina, announced May 8. [22] An additional $5 million follows on June 27. [24]
  4. VerifiedU.S. aid reaches $1,063 million, covering 78 percent of the cost of France's war. [23]

By the end, American taxpayers were paying most of the bill for a European power to reconquer its colony. The man who had quoted Jefferson was getting his weapons from Moscow and Beijing.

Count Four · 1954–1956

The Election That Never Came

VerifiedFrance lost at Dien Bien Phu in 1954. The Geneva Accords split Vietnam temporarily and called for national elections in 1956.

VerifiedPresident Eisenhower later wrote that, had elections been held during the fighting, "possibly 80 per cent of the population" would have voted for Ho over the French-backed chief of state, Bao Dai. [25][74]

VerifiedConvinced that Ho and his followers would win a free election, the Eisenhower administration installed Ngo Dinh Diem to lead South Vietnam and backed his refusal to hold the national vote. [26]

DisputedEisenhower's 80 percent figure described a vote against Bao Dai during the war, not against Diem in 1956. Historians still argue over how a 1956 vote would have gone. What is not disputed is that Washington backed blocking it.

For a country that sells itself to the world as democracy's defender, that is a hard sentence to read. The United States helped cancel an election because it expected to lose it.

Count Five · August 1964

The Attack That Never Happened

The legal basis for the Vietnam War was a resolution written months before the incident it was supposedly answering.

  1. VerifiedAdministration lawyers draft a congressional resolution authorizing force in Southeast Asia, months before any attack in the Gulf of Tonkin. [27]
  2. VerifiedSouth Vietnamese commando raids on the North Vietnamese coast, planned under a U.S. program called OPLAN 34A, are under way. The destroyer USS Maddox is patrolling nearby collecting signals intelligence. [33]
  3. VerifiedNorth Vietnamese torpedo boats attack the Maddox. This first clash was real. [27]
  4. VerifiedThe Maddox and USS Turner Joy report a second attack on a stormy night. The NSA's own historian later concluded the evidence did not support it. [31]
  5. VerifiedAfter 40 minutes of discussion, the House passes the resolution 416 to 0. The Senate passes it 88 to 2. [27]

What they told Congress

VerifiedAccording to the Pentagon's own Vietnam War 50th Anniversary history, Defense Secretary Robert McNamara lied to reporters on August 6 when he denied knowing the nature of the 34A raids. His own department ran them. Three days earlier he had told the President that some of the raids had led to the August 2 attack. [29]

VerifiedThe White House tapes show both Johnson and McNamara knew from the start that the Maddox mission was linked to the raids. [33][32]

"Hell, those damn, stupid sailors were just shooting at flying fish."President Lyndon Johnson, privately, after the resolution passed [28]

What the NSA found

VerifiedNSA historian Robert Hanyok reviewed 122 relevant signals-intelligence products. He found that the overwhelming portion of the evidence about August 4, nearly 90 percent, was kept out of the agency's post-attack summaries and its October 1964 final report. [30]

AttributedHanyok did not find a "smoking gun" proving a cover-up. He said the evidence suggested an active effort to make the intelligence fit the claim of an attack. [31] His study was written in 2001 and kept secret until its release in 2005.

VerifiedCongress repealed the Gulf of Tonkin Resolution in 1970. [33] By then the war had been running on it for six years.

Count Six · 1964–1968

What They Said When They Thought No One Was Listening

The President

VerifiedOn May 27, 1964, more than two months before Tonkin, Johnson spoke with his national security adviser, McGeorge Bundy, on a call recorded by the White House taping system. [35]

"I don't think that it's worth fighting for."President Lyndon Johnson on Vietnam, recorded May 27, 1964 [34]

In the same call he worried aloud about a sergeant on his staff with six children, and asked what in the world he would be sending such men there for. Then he sent more than half a million of them.

The Pentagon's real reasons

VerifiedIn a 1965 memo, Assistant Secretary of Defense John McNaughton weighted America's aims in Vietnam. [36]

Avoid a humiliating U.S. defeat (to our reputation as a guarantor)
70%
Keep South Vietnam and nearby territory from Chinese hands
20%
Give the people of South Vietnam a better, freer way of life
10%

Seventy percent of the reason was saving face. The reason given to the American public came last.

The secret history

VerifiedMcNamara ordered a secret internal history of the war, later known as the Pentagon Papers. Daniel Ellsberg leaked it in 1971. The government kept the complete study, about 7,000 pages, classified until June 2011. [37]

The candidate

AttributedIn October 1968, Johnson was trying to start peace talks. On October 22, Nixon aide H.R. Haldeman took notes on a call with candidate Richard Nixon. They record an order to keep Anna Chennault "working on" South Vietnam, and under the heading of the bombing halt, this question: [38][39]

"Any other way to monkey wrench it?"Haldeman's notes of a call with Richard Nixon, October 22, 1968 [38]

DisputedNixon denied interfering for the rest of his life. His foundation argues the note referred to political maneuvering against Johnson, not diplomatic sabotage, and that no deal was within reach. [40] See For the Record.

The Playbook Repeats

Different Wars, Same Script

Vietnam was supposed to be the lesson. In 1961, before the big escalation, a departing president who had commanded the largest invasion in history went on television and warned the country.

VerifiedOn January 17, 1961, in his farewell address, President Eisenhower warned against the "military-industrial complex." [68] The warning did not take.

Count Eight · 1990

The Girl Who Wasn't a Nurse

VerifiedOn October 10, 1990, a 15-year-old Kuwaiti girl identified only as "Nayirah" told the Congressional Human Rights Caucus that she had watched Iraqi soldiers take babies out of hospital incubators and leave them to die. [53]

VerifiedIn January 1992 it came out that she had never been a nurse. She was the daughter of Kuwait's ambassador to the United States. Her testimony was part of a public relations campaign that the Kuwaiti government-in-exile ran through a group called Citizens for a Free Kuwait, together with the American PR firm Hill & Knowlton. [51]

VerifiedPresident George H.W. Bush cited the incubator story as proof the war was necessary. Hill & Knowlton has denied wrongdoing. [52]

DisputedIraq really did invade Kuwait, and the war had other grounds. But the most emotional piece of the public case was staged. See For the Record.

Count Nine · 2002–2011

The Weapons That Weren't There

  1. VerifiedMinutes of a meeting in British Prime Minister Tony Blair's office record the head of British intelligence reporting back from Washington: "the intelligence and facts were being fixed around the policy." [54]
  2. VerifiedSecretary of State Colin Powell makes the case for war at the United Nations. On biological weapons, his main source is an informant code-named CURVEBALL. [57]
  3. The invasion begins.
  4. VerifiedThe chief U.S. weapons inspector, Charles Duelfer, reports that Saddam Hussein did not have weapons of mass destruction when the war began. [58]
  5. VerifiedA bipartisan majority of the Senate Intelligence Committee, 10 to 5, releases a report on whether officials' public statements about Iraq were backed by intelligence. [60] It finds the administration's claims that Iraq had a partnership with al-Qaeda were not supported. [59][61]

AttributedPowell later called the speech a "blot" on his record. In 2016 he said the President had already decided on military action by the time he spoke. [56]

Who got paid

VerifiedA Financial Times analysis found contractors received at least $138 billion for work tied to the Iraq war. At the top was KBR, formerly Kellogg Brown & Root, once run by Vice President Dick Cheney, with at least $39.5 billion. [62]

The bill

VerifiedAbout 4,500 U.S. service members died in Iraq. Iraq Body Count had recorded more than 114,000 civilian deaths by the end of 2011. [65]

VerifiedBrown University's Costs of War Project estimates the post-9/11 wars cost the U.S. more than $8 trillion through 2021, largely borrowed. It counts more than 900,000 people killed directly and an estimated 3.6 to 3.8 million indirect deaths in the war zones. [63][64]

Count Ten · 2001–2021

The Afghanistan Papers

VerifiedIn December 2019, the Washington Post published more than 2,000 pages of confidential government interviews about the war in Afghanistan. [67] The documents show high-ranking officials generally believed the war was unwinnable and kept that view hidden from the public. [66]

VerifiedThe Post reported that senior officials across three administrations made optimistic statements they knew were false and hid evidence the war had become unwinnable. [67]

Johnson's tapes, McNaughton's memo, and the Afghanistan Papers tell the same story fifty years apart. In private, they knew. In public, they said the opposite. Others did the dying.

Count Eleven · The Machinery

How They Sell It

No war on this page started because the public demanded it. Each one was sold. The sales method barely changes, and it works on people of every party.

Step 1: Hand the public one vivid story

A ship explodes. Torpedo boats attack in the dark. Babies are pulled from incubators. A vial of anthrax is held up at the United Nations. Each story was simple, emotional and presented as certain. Each one was wrong, staged or unproven (Counts One, Five, Eight and Nine).

Step 2: Control who explains it on TV

VerifiedIn 2008 the New York Times revealed that the Pentagon had recruited retired military officers who appeared on television as independent analysts of the Iraq war. The Pentagon gave them talking points and private briefings, and many had business ties to defense contractors. Viewers were not told. [78] Reporter David Barstow won a Pulitzer Prize for the investigation. [79]

Step 3: Repeat it until it feels true

VerifiedIn a September 2003 Washington Post poll, 69 percent of Americans said it was likely that Saddam Hussein was personally involved in the September 11 attacks. [80] There was no evidence for it. That same month, President Bush himself said there was no evidence Saddam was involved. [81] Nobody had to say the false thing outright. Saying "Saddam" and "9/11" in the same breath, again and again, was enough. [86]

Step 4: Make doubt look like disloyalty

Questioning the war becomes failing to "support the troops." That is how a resolution passes the House 416 to 0 after 40 minutes (Count Five). The only two senators who voted no on Tonkin, Wayne Morse and Ernest Gruening, turned out to be right. Both were out of the Senate after the 1968 election.

Step 5: Keep the people who decide far from the people who die

VerifiedGeorge Orwell fought in the Spanish Civil War and was shot through the throat. Afterward he wrote that the war propaganda and the hatred come invariably from people who are not fighting. [76]

VerifiedOn March 18, 2003, the day before the Iraq invasion began, former First Lady Barbara Bush, mother of the President, was asked on Good Morning America about television coverage of the coming war. She said she would not watch it, and asked about the talk of body bags and deaths: [75]

"Why should I waste my beautiful mind on something like that?"Barbara Bush, ABC's Good Morning America, March 18, 2003 [75]

Nearly 4,500 Americans did not get to look away from it (Count Nine).

Step 6: Put it on the credit card

VerifiedThe post-9/11 wars were paid for largely by borrowing. Brown University's Costs of War Project calls them "credit card wars." [63] No war tax was raised, so most families never felt the bill. They pay it anyway, twice: once in the taxes that cover the spending, and again in the interest on the debt, for decades.

Step 7: Never let it end

AttributedIn 1984, Orwell imagined a state at permanent war, where the real target is the population at home. In the novel, the object of the war is not to make or prevent conquests of territory but to keep the structure of society intact. [77] It is a novel, not a report. But a 20-year war in Afghanistan that officials privately called unwinnable (Count Ten) would not have surprised him.

Analysis · It works on everybody

It is tempting to say only the other side falls for this. The record says otherwise. Tonkin passed under a Democratic president with a unanimous House. The Iraq war was authorized with large majorities of both parties. The 69 percent who believed the Saddam–9/11 story came from across the spectrum.

The defense is the same for everyone. When the next war is being sold, ask Butler's three questions: Who is telling us why? Who makes money? Who does the dying? Then ask one more: what is the evidence, and who has seen it?

More on Crisis of Truth

The Evidence of a Pattern

The Racket, Step by Step

Analysis · Five wars, one script

  • The pretext comes first. A ship explodes, an attack that never happened, a coached witness, weapons that weren't there. Each was presented as certain before anyone checked.
  • Congress signs the blank check. 416 to 0 after 40 minutes in 1964. The power to declare war is handed over in a rush and taken back years later, if ever.
  • The doubts stay private. Johnson told Bundy the war wasn't worth it. McNaughton weighted face-saving at 70 percent. Afghanistan's officials called it unwinnable in interviews they assumed would stay secret.
  • The contractors get paid either way. Brown & Root in 1966, KBR in 2003. The same corporate family, the same no-questions money.
  • The truth arrives after the funerals. The Rickover study, 78 years after the Maine. Hanyok's study, 41 years after Tonkin. The full Pentagon Papers, 47 years after the Tonkin vote.

This does not require a conspiracy. It requires only what Butler described: a system where the people who profit from war have more say over it than the people who fight it. Nothing on this page needed a secret meeting. Most of it happened in the open, on the record, with a vote.

Commentary · The Publisher's Verdict

Who Answers for It?

This section is opinion, and it is labeled that way. Crisis of Truth puts every case through three questions.

1 · Is it legal?

Mostly, and that is the problem. Congress voted for the Tonkin Resolution. Congress voted for the Iraq war. The contracts were awarded under the law. The PR campaign was legal. The clearest exception is McNamara's false statement about the 34A raids, and no one was ever charged for it. If Haldeman's notes mean what Nixon's critics say, a private citizen interfered with the government's peace effort in wartime. No one was charged for that either.

2 · Is it constitutional?

It strains the Constitution past recognition. Article I gives Congress the power to declare war. Congress has not formally declared a war since 1942. Instead it signs open-ended authorizations, often on information the executive branch knows to be shaky. A power that can be handed away on 40 minutes of debate, based on an attack that didn't happen, is not functioning the way the framers designed it. The Constitution assumes Congress gets the truth before it votes. On Tonkin, it did not.

3 · Is it morally and ethically acceptable?

No. A president said on tape that the war wasn't worth fighting, then sent more than half a million men to fight it. A defense official ranked saving face above the lives of the people the war was supposedly for. A secretary of defense misled Congress about the raids that set off the incident. A candidate, by the notes of his own aide, looked for ways to wreck a peace effort while men were dying. Thirty-nine years later, a war was sold on weapons that didn't exist, and the company with the deepest political ties collected the most money.

Smedley Butler earned two Medals of Honor and then spent his last years warning Americans that their sons were being spent for someone else's profit. The record since 1935 has not proved him wrong once.

The people who made these decisions mostly died rich and honored. The people who paid for them are on a black granite wall in Washington, in cemeteries across Vietnam and Iraq, and in VA hospitals today. Remembering that is the least we owe them. Asking Butler's three questions before the next war is the most.

Disagree? The strongest case against this verdict is in For the Record, and you should read it.

These claims circulate widely, several of them in the video at the top of this page. We could not confirm them against a primary source, or we found that the record says something different. We list them so readers can see what we left out and why.

"17,000 workers died on one Michelin plantation."We found no source for this number. It appears to be a mix-up with the 17,606 laborers brought to Phu Rieng in 1927. The verified figure is that colonial records showed 17 percent of Phu Rieng's workers died that year.
A French official named "De Rouso" wrote that peasants should be deliberately impoverished.We could not find this official or this report. Until someone produces the document, it stays here.
"Over 80% of Vietnamese land was under French control" by the 1930s.We found no source supporting this figure. The video gives none, and it hedges by counting French colonists "and their allies" together.
"Over 90%" of the Tonkin intelligence was skewed, and the attack was "deliberately fabricated."The NSA historian's figure is nearly 90 percent withheld, and he said he found no smoking gun proving a cover-up. "Distorted to fit the claim" is what the record supports.
"The Pentagon estimated North Vietnam could lose 200,000 men a year indefinitely."The figure usually cited is that about 200,000 North Vietnamese males reached draft age each year. We did not find the Pentagon estimate as the video states it.
Lyndon Johnson personally made billions from the war.His longtime backers at Brown & Root got the largest war construction contract of the era. We found no evidence that Johnson personally profited from Vietnam contracts.
Bao Dai "owned a casino and drove a Ferrari."His playboy reputation is well documented. We did not verify these specific details. He was chief of state in 1954, not emperor; he had abdicated in 1945.
"The dominoes never fell."Thailand, Indonesia and the Philippines did not fall. But Laos and Cambodia both came under communist rule in 1975, and the Khmer Rouge genocide followed.
Butler's testimony named Prescott Bush and the du Ponts.These names circulate in many retellings of the Business Plot. We did not confirm them against the committee record, and the committee excluded much of the testimony about named figures as hearsay.
William Randolph Hearst blew up the Maine.His newspapers pushed the war. We found no evidence he had anything to do with the explosion.
Nayirah's testimony "started" the Gulf War.It was the most emotional piece of the public case. Iraq's invasion of Kuwait and the UN vote authorizing force stand independently of it.
"When exposing a crime is treated as committing a crime, you are being ruled by criminals." —Edward SnowdenThis line circulates on Snowden's photo, and on other whistleblowers'. We could not trace it to anything Snowden said or wrote.
"Dear America: You are waking up, as Germany once did…" —Werner HerzogFact-checkers found Herzog never said it. [82][83]
"Prescott Bush helped Hitler rise to power," with a photo of the two together.What is documented: in October 1942 the U.S. government seized the Union Banking Corporation, where Prescott Bush was a director, under the Trading with the Enemy Act. The bank was tied to German industrialist Fritz Thyssen, an early financial backer of Hitler. [84][85] What is not: the viral photo, which we could not confirm shows Bush, and the claim that he or Wall Street made Hitler's rise or the Holocaust possible.

For the Record

The Strongest Case Against This Page

Crisis of Truth publishes the best counterarguments on every case file. A critique that cannot survive these is not worth reading.

Ho Chi Minh was a committed communist long before 1945. Ho was a founding member of the French Communist Party in 1920 and became an agent of the Communist International in Moscow in 1923. [69] Archival research also challenges the story that Woodrow Wilson's indifference radicalized him; in 1919–20 he was himself pushing French socialists toward Lenin's International. [70] Many historians conclude he was both a nationalist and a committed communist. The "we pushed him into Moscow's arms" story is at best half the picture.
The U.S. was trying to stop communism, not prop up a colony. The Pentagon Papers describe the rationale for aiding France as keeping Indochina from sliding into the communist camp, rather than supporting France as a colonial power. [23] Aid came in 1950, after China fell to Mao, not in 1945.
The war bought time for the rest of Southeast Asia. Singapore's Lee Kuan Yew argued for decades that the war bought time for non-communist states to grow strong. He used that phrase with U.S. officials during the war. [71] A recent scholarly assessment found some truth in the claim that the war strengthened the region's non-communist states, while calling the argument morally bankrupt as a justification for the cost. [73]
Congress knew it might be voting for war. The August 2 attack was real. The Council on Foreign Relations notes that the text of the Senate debate suggests members understood what they were authorizing, despite later claims that they didn't. [27]
Nixon's defenders say the "monkey wrench" note is being misread. The Nixon Foundation argues the note referred to fighting Johnson politically over the bombing halt, and that no peace deal was within reach in 1968. [40]
The Iraq failure was the intelligence agencies', not just the White House's. The same 2008 Senate report found that intelligence supported most of the administration's prewar statements about weapons programs. Republicans pointed out that Democratic senators made similar statements based on the same intelligence. [61] The Downing Street phrase "fixed around" may mean selectively interpreted rather than invented. [55]
The Gulf War had a legitimate basis. Iraq invaded and occupied Kuwait. Amnesty International initially corroborated the incubator reports before issuing a correction. [51] The war's justification did not rest on one witness.
The Nye Committee never proved its theory. By the end of the hearings, the committee members were almost unanimous that the evidence did not support the "merchants of death" theory that arms makers caused U.S. entry into World War I. [10]
Contractors did real work, legally. KBR says it performed with honor in a hostile, unpredictable environment, serving more than a billion meals and producing more than 25 billion gallons of drinkable water. [62] Contracting is legal, and cost-plus contracts were authorized by Congress.
The Maine may not have been an accident. The Navy's own history director notes weaknesses in the coal-fire theory as well as the mine theory. [12] The cause has never been conclusively established.
The Business Plot was doubted at the time. The men Butler named denied it, the press ridiculed it, and the committee declined to call the most prominent figures. [6][8] Its seriousness is still debated.
The Vietnamese death toll is contested in both directions. Estimates differ by a factor of three. Vietnam's government estimate is higher than most demographic studies. [49][50]

Sources

The Record

  1. Wikipedia, "War Is a Racket" (speech tour, 1935 publication, Butler's three steps). wikipedia.org
  2. Smedley D. Butler, War Is a Racket (1935), full text, Internet Archive. archive.org
  3. U.S. Marine Corps History Division, "Maj Smedley Darlington Butler," Medal of Honor recipients. usmcu.edu
  4. Wikipedia, "Common Sense (American magazine)" (Butler's 1935 statement). wikipedia.org · Philosophical Society, Butler excerpt. philosophicalsociety.com
  5. Smedley D. Butler, "America's Armed Forces," Common Sense, Vol. 4, No. 11 (Nov. 1935), via Montclair State University. montclair.edu
  6. Wikipedia, "Business Plot." wikipedia.org
  7. Saturday Evening Post, "Considering History: The 1933 Business Plot to Overthrow America" (2023); New England Historical Society, committee report. saturdayeveningpost.com · newenglandhistoricalsociety.com
  8. Libertarianism.org (Cato Institute), "Smedley Butler & the 'Business Plot,' Part I" (includes testimony). libertarianism.org
  9. U.S. Senate, "Merchants of Death" (Nye Committee). senate.gov
  10. Wikipedia, "Nye Committee." wikipedia.org
  11. History News Network, review of Jonathan M. Katz, Gangsters of Capitalism. historynewsnetwork.org
  12. Naval History and Heritage Command, H-Gram 015-3, "Remember the Maine! To Hell with Spain!" history.navy.mil
  13. U.S. Naval Institute, Naval History, "What Really Sank the Maine?" (April 1998). usni.org
  14. Tran Tu Binh, The Red Earth: A Vietnamese Memoir of Life on a Colonial Rubber Plantation (Ohio University). mitpressbookstore.mit.edu
  15. Wikipedia (2007 archive), "Phu Rieng Do" (citing Tran Tu Binh and colonial records). classicistranieri.com
  16. Binh Phuoc Province Tourism, Phu Rieng Party cell national historical relic. binhphuoc.gov.vn
  17. National WWII Museum, "The OSS in Vietnam, 1945: A War of Missed Opportunities." nationalww2museum.org
  18. Military.com, "America's Secret WWII OSS Mission in Vietnam to Arm Ho Chi Minh Against Japan" (Oct. 2025). military.com
  19. HistoryNet, "How American Operatives Saved the Man Who Started the Vietnam War." historynet.com
  20. National Archives, DocsTeach, Letter from Ho Chi Minh to President Truman, Jan. 18, 1946. docsteach.org
  21. National Archives, "Episode 1: Truman Sides With France." archives.gov
  22. Pentagon Papers, Part IV.A.2, "Aid for France in Indochina, 1950–1954," Summary. wikisource.org · Document index. wikisource.org
  23. Pentagon Papers, Part II, p. 43 (aid reached $1,063 million, 78% of French costs). wikisource.org
  24. Foreign Relations of the United States, 1950, Vol. VI, Doc. 533. history.state.gov
  25. Dwight D. Eisenhower, Mandate for Change, p. 372, via Montclair State University. montclair.edu
  26. Hewitt & Lawson, Exploring American Histories, "Early U.S. Intervention in Vietnam" (Macmillan). macmillanusa.com
  27. Council on Foreign Relations, "The 1964 Gulf of Tonkin Resolution." cfr.org
  28. Council on Foreign Relations, "Ten Worst Decisions: Gulf of Tonkin Resolution." cfr.org
  29. U.S. Department of Defense, Vietnam War 50th Anniversary Commemoration, "Aftermath of the Gulf of Tonkin Incident." vietnamwar50th.com
  30. Robert J. Hanyok, NSA, "Skunks, Bogies, Silent Hounds, and the Flying Fish: The Gulf of Tonkin Mystery," via Navy Department Library. history.navy.mil
  31. National Security Archive, "Tonkin Gulf Intelligence 'Skewed'" (Dec. 1, 2005). nsarchive.gwu.edu · History News Network. hnn.us
  32. National Security Archive, LBJ tapes on the Gulf of Tonkin. nsarchive.gwu.edu
  33. The American Legion Magazine, John Prados, "The Mysteries of Tonkin Gulf" (Feb. 2013). legion.org
  34. Bill Moyers Journal, "Listening to History," transcript of LBJ–Bundy call (2007). billmoyers.com
  35. Not Even Past (University of Texas), on the May 27, 1964 recording (Johnson Library Tape 64.28). notevenpast.org
  36. Famous Trials, Pentagon Papers excerpts (McNaughton weighting). famous-trials.com · Museo Reina Sofía, full 70/20/10 text. museoreinasofia.es
  37. NPR, "After 40 Years, Pentagon Papers Declassified In Full" (June 13, 2011). npr.org
  38. National Archives, DocsTeach, "H. R. Haldeman's Notes," Oct. 22, 1968. docsteach.org
  39. Smithsonian Magazine, "Notes Indicate Nixon Interfered With 1968 Peace Talks." smithsonianmag.com
  40. Richard Nixon Foundation, Jack Torry, "Did Nixon deliberately prolong Vietnam War?" nixonfoundation.org
  41. Wikipedia, "RMK-BRJ" (final contract value). wikipedia.org
  42. NPR via History News Network, Brown & Root and Lyndon Johnson (quoting Robert Caro). historynewsnetwork.org
  43. JSTOR Daily, "The Logistics That Powered the Vietnam War." daily.jstor.org
  44. CorpWatch, "US: Perpetual Wars Deliver Poor Returns for America" (Rumsfeld on RMK-BRJ). corpwatch.org
  45. History.com, "Vietnam veterans exposed to Agent Orange win $180 million settlement." history.com
  46. Arizona State University, Embryo Project, "In re Agent Orange Product Liability Litigation." asu.edu
  47. The Nation, Vietnamese Agent Orange claims dismissed. thenation.com
  48. National Archives, "Vietnam War U.S. Military Fatal Casualty Statistics." archives.gov
  49. Merli (2000), citing Hirschman et al. (1995), Vietnamese war mortality estimate, UC Berkeley. berkeley.edu · Wikipedia, "Vietnam War casualties." wikipedia.org
  50. Bill Moyers, excerpt from Nick Turse, Kill Anything That Moves (Vietnamese government estimate). billmoyers.com
  51. Wikipedia, "Nayirah testimony." wikipedia.org
  52. MERIP, "The News Industry" (1992). merip.org
  53. Democracy Now!, interview with John R. MacArthur (2018). democracynow.org
  54. Wikipedia, "Downing Street memo." wikipedia.org
  55. Slate, Fred Kaplan, on reading the Downing Street memo. slate.com
  56. Wikipedia, "Colin Powell's presentation to the United Nations Security Council." wikipedia.org
  57. National Security Archive, Electronic Briefing Book 234, CURVEBALL. nsarchive.gwu.edu
  58. CNN, "Report: No WMD stockpiles in Iraq" (Oct. 6, 2004). cnn.com
  59. U.S. Senate Select Committee on Intelligence, "Senate Intelligence Committee Unveils Final Phase II Reports on Prewar Iraq Intelligence" (June 5, 2008). intelligence.senate.gov
  60. U.S. Government Publishing Office, Senate Report 110-345. gpo.gov
  61. NBC News, "Senate report puts Iraq intel back in spotlight" (2008). nbcnews.com
  62. Iraq Business News, "Contractors Get $138bn from Iraq War" (Financial Times research, March 2013). iraq-businessnews.com
  63. Brown University, Costs of War Project, "Overview: The True Costs of the Post-9/11 Wars." brown.edu
  64. Brown University, "Costs of the 20-year war on terror: $8 trillion and 900,000 deaths" (Sept. 1, 2021). brown.edu
  65. Dawn (AFP), Iraq Body Count end-of-2011 tally. dawn.com
  66. Wikipedia, "Afghanistan Papers." wikipedia.org
  67. Voice of America, "Washington Post: Government Study Shows US Officials Misled Public on Afghan War" (Dec. 2019). voanews.com
  68. National Archives, "President Dwight D. Eisenhower's Farewell Address (1961)." archives.gov
  69. Cambridge University Press, chapter on Ho Chi Minh and the origins of Vietnamese communism. cambridge.org
  70. Wilson Center, Brett Reilly, "The Myth of the Wilsonian Moment." wilsoncenter.org
  71. Foreign Relations of the United States, 1964–68, Vol. XXVI, Doc. 284, Rusk to Johnson on Lee Kuan Yew. history.state.gov
  72. YouTube, "The True Origin of the Vietnam War: What Historians Get Wrong." youtube.com
  73. Inside Story, Graeme Dobell, "Domino days" (review of Fibiger on the "buying time" thesis). insidestory.org.au
  74. Texas Observer (1967), full Eisenhower quotation including "rather than chief of state Bao Dai." texasobserver.org
  75. Snopes, Barbara Bush "beautiful mind" quote (Good Morning America, March 18, 2003). snopes.com
  76. George Orwell, "Looking Back on the Spanish War" (1943), via libcom.org. libcom.org
  77. George Orwell, Nineteen Eighty-Four (1949), Part Two, Chapter 9; quotation collection. goodreads.com
  78. Wikipedia, "Pentagon military analyst program" (New York Times, April 2008). wikipedia.org
  79. Pulitzer Prizes, David Barstow of The New York Times. pulitzer.org
  80. Arab News (AP), "69% of Americans Believe Saddam Linked to 9/11: Poll" (Sept. 2003). arabnews.com
  81. CBS News, "Bush: No Saddam Links To 9/11" (Sept. 2003). cbsnews.com
  82. PolitiFact, "No, Werner Herzog didn't say that about America and Germany" (2019). politifact.com
  83. Snopes, "Did Werner Herzog Tweet America is 'Waking Up, As Germany Once Did'?" snopes.com
  84. The Guardian via History News Network, "How Bush's grandfather helped Hitler's rise to power" (2004). historynewsnetwork.org
  85. Mail & Guardian, "Bush and the Hitler connection" (Sept. 2004). mg.co.za
  86. Pew Research Center, "A Look Back at How Fear and False Beliefs Bolstered U.S. Public Support for War in Iraq." pewresearch.org

Found an error? It goes in the public corrections ledger.